Carrie Underwood made a virtual appearance on The Tonight Show Starring Jimmy Fallon on Dec. 3.

In addition to chatting with the titular host, Carrie treated viewers to a beautiful rendition of “O Holy Night.”

The tune is featured on Carrie’s recent Christmas album, My Gift. Composed in the mid-1800s by Adolphe Adam and John Sullivan Dwight, “O Holy Night” is a holiday staple that has been recorded by a number of A-list artists, including Mariah Carey, John Berry, Josh Groban, Martina McBride and more.

Carrie’s new 11-song album features a combination of beloved traditional favorites, such as “Silent Night” and “Away in the Manger,” as well as original material, including “Sweet Baby Jesus” and “Let There Be Peace.”

Watch Carrie sing “O Holy Night” below.